Nine models on Amazon, from 12.25 by 8.75 inches up to 13 by 18 inches. Six carry a non-stick surface, three are uncoated, and they run across three product lines: Commercial II, Professional, and Uncoated Textured.
The range covers quarter sheet and half sheet dimensions, the two classic jelly roll sizes, and one cooling rack sized to match the larger pans.
Interior dimensions run smaller than the exterior figure in each product name, and both are given below where the manufacturer publishes them.
4.6 / 5 · 2,349 ratings
4.7 / 5 · 1,067 ratings
4.6 / 5 · 2,170 ratings
4.6 / 5 · 2,349 ratings
4.6 / 5 · 272 ratings
4.6 / 5 · 462 ratings
4.8 / 5 · 57 ratings
4.5 / 5 · 70 ratings
4.6 / 5 · 260 ratings
| Model | Size | Coating | Line | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
49150 | 15 × 10 in | Uncoated | Commercial II | 4.6 (2,349) |
59011 | 12.25 × 8.75 in | Non-Stick | Commercial II | 4.7 (1,067) |
16833 | 17 × 12.25 in, set of 2 | Non-Stick | Professional | 4.6 (2,170) |
49823 | 16.75 × 12 in, set of 2 | Uncoated | Commercial II | 4.6 (2,349) |
59813 | 17.75 × 12.75 in | Non-Stick | – | 4.6 (272) |
16150 | 14.75 × 9.75 in | Non-Stick | Professional | 4.6 (462) |
5234613 | 13 × 18 in | Uncoated | Uncoated Textured | 4.8 (57) |
17713 | 17.25 × 11.75 in | Non-Stick | – | 4.5 (70) |
16561 | 16.75 × 11.75 in, rack | Non-Stick | Professional | 4.6 (260) |
Commercial kitchens work from a fixed ladder of pan sizes: full at 26 by 18 inches, half at 18 by 13, quarter at 13 by 9. This range covers two rungs of that ladder plus the older jelly roll dimensions that predate it.
Model 59011 sits close to a commercial quarter sheet. It fits a toaster oven or countertop oven and holds a single tray of cookies. Steel with a dual-layer non-stick coating, rated 4.7 stars across 1,067 ratings.
Jelly roll pans predate commercial sizing and keep a one-inch wall. Model 49150 gives 15 by 10 outside with a 14.75 by 9.75 by 1 interior, the dimension American sponge-cake recipes assume. Model 49823 ships as a pair at 16.75 by 12. Both are uncoated heavy-weight aluminized steel with wire-rod reinforced rims.
Model 5234613 measures 13 by 18 inches, matching a commercial half sheet. It is the largest pan in the range and the only one that publishes a metal thickness, 1.0 mm aluminum. Rated 4.8 stars from 57 ratings.
Full-size pans at 26 by 18 inches and the StayFlat commercial series sell through foodservice supply channels rather than Amazon. Model numbers 40700, 40950, 41555 and 30850 belong to that catalogue and are not part of the range on this page.
Half sheet at 13 by 18 is the largest size that fits a standard 30-inch home oven. On warp resistance, the consumer equivalent is the wire-rod reinforced rim, present on models 49150, 49823, 59813 and 5234613, where the rod is encapsulated in the rolled edge to stiffen the pan as it heats.
Six models are coated and three are not. The two groups behave differently in browning, release and cleaning.
Models 59011 and 59813 use a dual-layer coating. Models 16833, 16150 and 17713 use a single non-stick surface, and the 16561 rack uses a silicone-based coating. Food releases without greasing. Chicago Metallic recommends hand washing on these pans, including the ones its listings mark dishwasher safe.
Models 49150 and 49823 carry no coating. Aluminized steel browns more aggressively than a coated surface, which suits cookie bottoms and roasted vegetables. There is no surface layer to flake or degrade. These pans require greasing or lining, and cleaning is by hand.
Model 5234613 uses a stamped texture on the base that reduces contact between dough and metal, allowing air underneath and release without a coating. Aluminum conducts heat faster than steel. Hand wash only, and the only model in this group listed with a Lifetime Limited Warranty.
Three line names appear across these nine models.
Only 5234613 publishes a metal thickness. Commercial II and Professional listings give no gauge figure, so the lines cannot be compared on metal weight.
Ratings across the nine models run from 4.5 to 4.8 stars, with the two highest-volume pans at 4.6 and 4.7 across more than 1,000 ratings each. The brand sits between supermarket bakeware and premium American-made lines such as USA Pan, with construction carried over from commercial baking pans.
Some coated pans are listed as dishwasher safe, and Chicago Metallic recommends hand washing on those same pans to protect the coating. Model 5234613, the Uncoated Textured Aluminum sheet, is hand wash only.
Among these baking sheets, Professional models are all coated carbon or heavy-gauge steel. Commercial II includes both uncoated aluminized steel jelly roll pans and one coated steel sheet, so the line name does not indicate the surface. Neither line publishes a metal thickness.
Model 5234613 measures 13 by 18 inches, matching a commercial half sheet. Full-size pans at 26 by 18 inches and the StayFlat commercial series sell through foodservice supply channels rather than Amazon, and a full-size pan does not fit a standard 30-inch home oven.
Uncoated aluminized steel has no surface layer to wear away, so models 49150 and 49823 hold up longer in frequent use, with greasing and hand cleaning required. Non-stick surfaces last longer when hand washed, which is the manufacturer’s recommendation even on pans marked dishwasher safe.
Chicago Metallic Commercial II Traditional Uncoated True Jelly Roll Pan, Make jelly rolls, cookies, pizza, one-pan meals, and more, 15-Inch by 10-InchBuy on Amazon
